Ken, John and guest Ted Cohen , author of Jokes: Philosophical Thoughts on Joking Matters discuss the philosophical aspects of humor. What is humor? What makes some jokes funny? Why did the chicken cross the road? Tune in for deep thoughts and big laughs.
Conundrum (Seek To 00:53:05): This time, its our own Nicole Sawaya calling in with a perplexing question. Why would somebody pay for something that they could get for free? Say I can get something for free that wasnt free to make, produce, or construct. Is it right for me not to make a contribution?
Where do we start, or where should we start, a serious philosophical inquiry into humor? Perhaps humor is objective. Perhaps there is a right or wrong answer to the question of whether a joke is funny or not. But if I think a joke is funny and you dont, does that make one of us right and the other Philosophy Talk, Humorwrong? It could be the case that, just like the taste of applesauce, the question of whether or not its good is subjective. John points out that, however strange Kants theory may be, it tends to rightly claim that humor is subjective.
Most people would agree that laughter and humor are necessary and valuable forms of human expression. After all, what would life be like without humor? Are there philosophical theories of humor? There are some. Kant, as John explains Humor, has a rather absurd theory of humor that he finds particularly interesting if not in the least convincing. According to John, Kants theory is so entertaining because he backs it up with a few jokes. Of course, as Ken remarks, Kant telling a joke is humor in itself.
Individual episodes,new york asian escort model multipacks and The Complete Philosophy Talk on sale now through Iamplify. Individual episodes available through Itunes and CD Baby.
Philosophy Talk relies on the support of listeners like you to stay on the air and online. Any contribution, large or small, helps us produce intelligent, reflective radio that questions everything, including our most deeply-held beliefs about science, morality, culture, and the human condition. Make your tax-deductible contribution now through Stanford Universitys secure online donation page. Thank you for your support, and thank you for thinking!
Philosophy Talk With Ken Taylor and John Perry of Stanford University is produced by Ben Manilla Productions, Inc..
Looking at Kant, Freud, and others, it seems that one of the problems with the theories they put forward about humor is their lack of miliarity with the data. That is, they have bad jokes or, more precisely, they dont know what a good joke is. Naturally, as guest Ted Cohen puts it, it would be a miracle of their theories turned out right. Cohen wrote a book in which he argued that there is no theory of jokes. Some people find some jokes funny; other people dont find the same jokes funny. What you can speak to is the types of jokes people find funny and how those jokes work in getting people to laugh. But beyond that, there doesnt seem to be much to say.
Jo Anna Isaak. Feminism and Contemporary Art: The Revolutionary Power of Womens Laughter. (Routledge 1996).